Ask Stew: What’s Better? Working Out Once vs. Multiple Times Per Day

Share
Sgt. Caleb Lamb competes in the max-pullups event during the Ultimate Warrior Competition, June 10, 2025. Service members from across Fort Meade, Maryland, participated in an Ultimate Warrior Competition. Events included max pullups, max pushups, dead hang, 1,000-meter row and max deadlift. (Abigail Carey/Army)

Many ways exist to improve calisthenics scores on fitness tests, including exercises such as pushups and pullups. While the first rep is a strength exercise, the higher volume required to excel on these tests demands muscle stamina (strength-endurance). Here is a common question from a reader who is mixing different approaches in order to see results throughout the year:

Stew, what do you think of sub-maximal sets spread throughout the day, such as pullups or pushups, versus a single workout with these calisthenic exercises, to improve fitness on fitness tests? Thanks, Ken.

The methodology for improving maximum-repetition calisthenics exercises combines strength first and volume over time. The quick answer is both. However, if you have done only one of these workout types and are stuck on a plateau, doing the other is a great way to break through that plateau and see more reps in your scoring. If you continue to see results with what you are doing, be patient and keep going. Consistency is key, but eventually you may need another version of the stimulus on the muscles responsible for more reps of pullups and pushups. Here is a breakdown of how to use both:

Sub-Maximal Sets Throughout the Day

The goal with multiple sets of pullups and pushups is to perform 50%-60% of your current max reps to increase total volume for the day. You should do this every other day, but some protocols may have you following this daily routine for a short period of 10-14 days. Daily reps at a high volume for too long usually result in stagnation or negative scores and could even lead to overuse injuries in the shoulders and elbows, such as tendonitis.

This method is highly effective for increasing volume without causing failure or fatigue, which allows for better application of technique and perfect form repetitions. This is how you build muscle stamina and break through plateaus when doing normal workout split routines (upper body/lower body) on consecutive days throughout the week.

Single Workout (Max Reps, Pyramids, Super Sets)

Many ways exist to increase volume, and max rep workouts, pyramids and super sets are easily the most common among military members looking to improve PT scores on fitness tests. This involves doing all your repetitions in a single upper-body session lasting 30-60 minutes. The benefits of this type of workout are building work capacity and mental toughness to keep training when physically fatigued. These are the type of workout in which you can simulate the fitness test and work on your speed, pace and form for the time you will be tested.

Or do both each upper-body day.

As you build up the training volume, routines of 100-plus pullups and 200-300 pushups are not recommended daily. However, every other day works well as you progress to higher repetitions of this type. Three workouts a week is perfect, but later in the same day, you can add some extra repetitions in small sets spread out if you want more volume and practice with perfect form. Try this type of week

Workout 1: PT Pyramid to Build Volume and Max Effort

  • 1 pullup/2 pushups
  • 2 pullups/4 pushups, 
  • 3/6 …

Continue up the pyramid until you fail. Then repeat in reverse order. Think of this workout as a warmup, a max-out and a cooldown all in one. Include active rest by running.

Workout 2: Sub-Max-Effort Set to Build Volume

Sub-max-effort super sets (example: 10-15 sets of 5-10 pullups/20 pushups) to build volume without failure. Include active rest by running.

Workout 3: Max-Rep Sets to Push Perceived Limits and Test Endurance

Perform max-rep sets in a round-robin circuit to test endurance. Include active rest by running.
Think workouts such as the Murph, in which you set a goal of 100 pullups, 200 pushups and any other exercise (squats, situps, dips, etc.); and do maximum-effort sets until those numbers are reached. Try in as few sets as possible.

The Bottom Line

Use spread-out sets to build the capacity (total daily reps), and use single-session workouts to test that capacity. By adding an active rest of running to the workout, you can help yourself with the test, as running usually follows these exercises in military fitness tests. Check out the Military.com Fitness Section for more ideas of this type of training. There are hundreds of articles showing even more workouts you can introduce to your training week if you feel you need a change. 

Want to Learn More About Military Life?

Whether you're thinking of joining the military, looking for fitness and basic training tips, or keeping up with military life and benefits, Military.com has you covered. Subscribe to Military.com to have military news, updates and resources delivered directly to your inbox.

Share